Showing posts with label Germany. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Germany. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 28, 2012

The UK's Big Society vs Germany's bürgerschaftliches Engagement - spot the difference



This blog post is still very much "under construction" - your comments or thoughts are all the more welcome. 

It's been very interesting crossing over from the UK to Germany in terms of witnessing the same debate around the renegotiation of the relationship between government and its citizens taking a very different shape.

The UK's Big Society
In the UK the debate was invigorated by David Cameron's 2008 "Big Society" initiative which was presented as his big, exciting and new idea even though it wasn't really his idea and it wasn't new either.

The Big Society initiative was launched in 2008, in tandem with the most drastic programme of cuts to public spending seen in the UK since the Second World War, made necessary by the high level of government debt caused by the financial crisis. That coincidence (in the temporal sense of the word) gave the Big Society initiative both a sense of urgency and a legitimacy deficit as it was easily caricatured as the government's enthusiastic support for citizens delivering public services themselves so it could reduce the services' budgets. Even more serious critics denounced it as a devious strategy to divide and rule civil society to buffer the reaction to what the government knew would be very unpopular public spending cuts accompanied by a severe recession. Some civil society organisations would welcome the Big Society initiative as empowering, thereby preventing a unified civil society backlash against public spending cuts.

Some cheered at the prospects of bottom-up, local citizen initiatives being freed from red tape. Others feared increasingly uneven development with well-to-do areas able to take care of their own and deprived areas without the indigenous resources being even more left behind. In fact the Big Society seemed to be better received in the relatively comfortable middle-class areas in South-Eastern England, but simply out of touch in the harsher reality of Northern England.

Having been part of a "Big Society" project I have experienced the reality of this. This was for one a private sector that was too preoccupied with its own troubles and therefore reluctant to fund any ongoing programme that was too complex and ambitious to easily fit their PR strategy of simple, positive messages. On the other hand was a public sector that was trying to adjust to a minimum of 25% budget cuts and  desperately looking for innovative ways to provide the same amount of service with less. This defensive position certainly didn't increase the propensity to invest in some new initiative that didn't provide quick, direct, practical benefits. And the Big Society might be made out to be a lot of things but it is really not a quick-fix solution. If it should have been able to stand any chance of survival, the "Big Society" should have been launched 5 years ago but putting it out in the UK's economic climate of 2008 gave it a lethal birth defect. Why wasn't it launched earlier then? This article on the idea of the relational state suggests that the previous Labour government was too statist and institutional in its focus because it wanted to reduce social inequality mainly via redistribution of wealth. As a result it neglected the importance of human relationships for creating social impact. I imagine the Big Society idea would have seemed incompatible with Labour's approach to reducing social inequality.

Another perspective on why the Big Society was never able to take off is suggested by Tom Clark's article on the size of public sector outsourcing in the UK. Public sector commissioning contracts for public services are being awarded increasingly to a small number of multi-purpose companies like SERCO or G4S who provide all the services a government could possibly be looking for - from schools and health care to back-to-work programmes. As was demonstrated by last year's Work Programme contracting process, civil society-based organisations, who have the track record and the community-connections which are so crucial to creating social impact and solving society's "wicked problems", stand little chance of being awarded these contracts because they don't have the financial clout to pay the initial costs up front. It does strengthen the cynics' argument that the Big Society initiative was merely about offloading more government responsibilities onto its citizens while providing those citizens with ever fewer tools to do the work.

Germany's "bürgerschaftliches Engagement" (civic engagement)
In Germany the debate has been conducted under the headings of "befähigender Staat" (enabling state) and "bürgerschaftliches Engagement". The economic underpinnings and general climate surrounding the discussion couldn't be more different from that of the UK. Even though many local authorities are struggling too, federal tax income has never been higher and the labour market hasn't been as good in decades.

However, German society is facing quite the demographic and social cliff as its baby boomers are about to retire en masse with very few young workers remaining to pay for their parents' social and healthcare services and pensions. Some predict a labour shortage of some 7 million workers by 2030. Many rural areas and smaller towns and cities outside the economic heartlands are emptying at a drastic rate and are facing the collapse of their service infrastructures. There's a sense of "enjoy the now because the future can only get worse".

The question here is whether these relatively good times will be used to invest in the social infrastructure supporting increased civic engagement, which would pay off in the tough times ahead. Germany's challenge is that of how to realize a culture change towards more individual and communal citizen initiative rather than waiting or relying on government initiative. How can that be encouraged before it's too late and public services have to be cut back even more? The key to this culture change lies in the formation and expansion of relationships between diverse social networks. In these networks new possibilities can be imagined and realised. This culture change is already in progress and driven forward by actors like the national Network for Civic Engagement (BBE). Crucial to the way this process progresses are the German "Wohlfahrtsverbände" or charitable organisations. These organisations have a long history, going back to the turn of the 19th century, and have become over the years truly massive, national operations, funded mainly by various social and health-related public service contracts. One of them, the German Caritas, is one of the country's largest employer. They are the reason why private sector companies like SERCO and G4S are not yet very prominent in Germany.

But are they better at fostering a new relationship between government and citizens? They are trying to find new, user-enabling approaches to providing their services and due to their charitable status they can rely on many volunteers. However, they have an incentive to discourage their volunteers' initiative if it threatens their public service contracts.

As I wrote in the beginning, this post is still in draft form. So your comments are even more welcome!

Friday, November 16, 2012

Did the postmodern identity discussion skip Germany?


Persistent "Turks are Turks and not Germans" thinking

The following video (it's in German only) taken from a public TV broadcast in 2011, documents the discrimination of Turkish-German citizens in Bavarian clubs, whose owners get the bouncers to apply a "foreigner quota" to limit the number of foreigners (particularly Turkish-Germans) in the clubs due the the supposed higher security risk they represent. In particular Josef Zellmeier, conservative local politician, tries to justify the quota by claiming  how the foreigners' culture supposedly makes them more prone to violence, whereas German culture is further developed and therefore less violent. Just imagine the outrage this headline alone would cause for example in the British press. This guys political career would be over, save if he joined the BNP. In Germany he is a senior local politician for the establishment centre-right CSU party. He faced no repercussions due to the broadcast in the German press.


Actually it's a German problem

Besides the blatant racism towards Turkish-German citizens, displayed equally by young club-goers, the seasoned local politician as well as the broadcast's presenter, what is extremely striking is that at no point do the discussants considered that these supposed 'foreigners' are as German as can be. They have been born in Germany, went to school in Germany, work in Germany. Germany is their place of residence and belonging. Any violence some individuals might be prone to is a German problem, caused by factors in the German environment they grew up in.

The political use of the "us vs them" thinking

The discussion displayed in the video is not representative of the wider national discussion, but it serves as an extreme example of the lack of awareness of a diverse German cultural and ethnic identity. In the late 90s the discussion centred around the illfated term of German "Leitkultur" or 'guiding culture' which migrants were supposed to assimilate into. Even thought the term was quickly dropped because people realised that one could not seriously claim that eating Sauerkraut or listening to Humpa music were the linchpins of German culture, the idea that migrants were not part of the 'guiding culture' remained.

More recently Angela Merkel revived that idea by officially pronouncing German multiculturalism dead and ringing in a renewed push for cultural integration of migrants. Her move was intended to position her conservative party further to the right on integration issues because of the shooting star popularity of Thilo Sarazin's populist anti-immigrant book "Germany does itself away" was threatening to make her look soft on integration. Last year, the mayor of Berlin's district with the highest migrant-population, has revived the debate again by writing an angry book about all the anti-social, criminal Turks and Arabs making it impossible for his district to improve its image.

The fault of multiculturalism?

For Angela Merkel to pronounce multiculturalism dead was of course like flogging a dead horse as it had long been seen as a failed policy by many experts exactly because it propagated the view and experience of separate cultural identities living side-by-side, kept together only by a thin veil of tolerance - an argument put brilliantly here by Slavoj Zizek. So the multiculturalist agenda is at least in part responsible for the popular "us-and-them" perspective on Germany's ethnic minorities.

Looking at similar migration-waves in Britain, it is hard to comprehend that more than 50 years after the first Turkish guest workers were asked to come to Germany, they and their children are still not accepted as German as anybody else living in this country in the popular discourse and by a range of populist politicians. By implication it is still not generally accepted that historically Germany's citizens have always combined a hugely diverse array of cultures to make up the hybrid construction of what they considered German culture and identity.

A much more realistic assessment on the ground

The peculiar situation is that the daily lived reality in many German cities is for more advanced than the popular and political discourses would suggest. This documentary of the history of Turkish guestworkers in Germany showcases a number of Germans with Turkish background who could not imagine living anywhere else but in Germany, yet still embrace their Turkish heritage positively.

Speaking for many others in a similar situation, Michelin-star cook Ali Güngörmüs laments the fact that even though he grew up almost entirely in Germany, learned to cook in Bavaria and does not even know how to prepare Turkish food, he is still presented as the successfully integrated "Turk" or at max the "Turkish-German" cook even by the mainstream German media. See here for an example. 

When will the media and the politicians catch up with reality?

He expresses the hope that someday the journalists will be able to understand him just as the individual he is, who, despite his diversity of background, is firmly at home in Germany. He is in fact so much at home in Germany's (culinaric) culture that he is helping to shape it by his exquisite preparation of German dishes. How could anyone claim he was not German? Nevertheless, he would still have trouble getting in to some Bavarian clubs because some people still don't get that. 



Pondering the causes - a lack of "Empire experience"

When comparing the situation between Britain and Germany of course the Empire or Commonwealth factor also comes to mind - Germany has never had a long-term relationship with the populations of its colonies like Britain did and Turkey was, in any case, never a German colony. This deprives the relationship of even the faintest historical example of joint belonging or cultural reference points like language or the Queen. 

Pondering the causes II - guilt creates dangerous resentiments

Pondering the causes of this persistent symbolic exclusion or dissociation of Turkish-Germans from the German identity, I wonder whether it is a sign of German's insecurity around their national identity and to what extent that might have been caused by the post-WWII officially enforced guilt complex around national pride. This paper by psychoanalyst Arno Gruen supports this theory. He claims that our rejection of the other is based in our rejection 

However, historically, Germany's central-European position has always ensured a massive influx of non-German influences that contributed to German culture via trade or migrant-settlement. Additionally, at numerous points in history, large numbers of Germans who had lived outside of Germany for a long time came back and brought with them their experience of the "world out there" - be that the people who were forcefully resettled from Eastern Europe after WWII or more recently the many German students, graduates, scientists, artists, businesspeople etc. who spent significant amounts of time abroad before bringing those experiences back to Germany. So there should have been plenty of opportunities for Germans to experience and contemplate 'the stranger within us'/"Das Fremde in uns" and to adopt a more realistic and flexible view of their own culture and relativise their "us vs them" attitude towards ethnic minority Germans. However, for some reason that has not happened on a wide scale so far.

Pondering the causes III - a destructive political strategy

In the face of the reality of a multitude of cultural influences on German culture, any portrayal of German identity as anything else than hybrid, complex and ever-changing is a destructive political strategy. As in the video from the beginning, it is aimed to garner one group's support by blaming a common problem (young men drinking too much and having fights in clubs) on another group that is supposedly 'culturally less developed' or more prone to violence because of their culture. Such a strategy is misanthropic and destructive and it is time this dimension dawned on Germany's press and politicians before reality catches up with them.